Paleo Marshmallows and Hot Chocolate

This recipe will not only rock your world but will rock your kids’ worlds and all those to whom you choose to bless with a DIY delicioso gift! These Paleo Marshmallows and  Hot Chocolate are made from healthy, real food ingredients. I’m taking it one step further by making this all into a gift using my instructions. You, my friend, are going to love knowing you are feeding your family and friends something they not only WANT this time of year, but their bodies actually need. Don’t believe me? Read on… Marshmallows are typically made from corn syrup, gelatin, sugar and assorted other ingredients (mostly unpronounceable). These marshmallows, however, are made with grass-fed gelatin and honey. The only other ingredients involved are water and something to roll them in if you choose to – tapioca starch for plain or cocoa powder, cinnamon or toasted coconut for flavored.

Why Make Paleo Marshmallows and Hot Chocolate?

Now you are wondering how our bodies need marshmallows. Well here’s the scoop…gelatin is a major ingredient and our bodies need and LOVE it. Gelatin is a form of collagen. We know it mostly for how it makes jiggly food (and drinks in some cases!) but the truth is collagen, in all of its forms, provides many health benefits. According to this article on the Vital Protein blog, “Lively”, grass-fed beef gelatin may help ease digestion, strengthen joints and bones, and improve the health of hair, skin, and nails.  The benefits of gelatin are great, and primarily helps the body digest food you might not be used to eating. Gelatin is slower to digest, moves through the GI tract further and coats the small intestine. This is beneficial in gut healing diets like GAPS, AIP, or SCD. (See the full article for references to back this up.)

I took the marshmallow recipe directly from Katie at Wellness Mama so I’m going to just give you the link rather than reprinting (and if you don’t already follow her…you should just sign up now…great info!!) but I wanted to show you the steps in photos since it’s sort of like candy making and seeing it come together will definitely help you. She offers several other variations including making the probiotic marshmallows by add a few capsules of your favorite probiotics. The small change I made was rolling the finished marshmallows in tapioca flour to keep them from sticking together. 

Step by Step Instructions

It seems like a lot of steps. Most of them are the method for cutting marshmallows. One time making these and it will come naturally.

Step One:

Combine ½ cup water with 4 tbsp gelatin in a large bowl; if using a stand mixer combine it in there. (I admittedly forgot to photo this actual first step.)

Step Two:

Combine 1 cup honey with another ½ cup water in a medium saucepan.

Step Three:

Let it come to a boil and boil continually for 8 minutes. If you have a candy thermometer this works much better since there is no guess work. You will be looking for 240 degrees.

Step Four:

With your mixer running on low (or with a hand mixer in your non-dominant hand), slowly drizzle the honey mixture into the gelatin. (Photo is bad, but you can at least see the stream of honey going in…) When all of it has been added, increase speed to medium until the mixture is the consistency of thick cream.

Step Five:

Increase speed to high and beat for about 15 minutes or until gentle peaks form. It will be the consistency of thick meringue. Add the vanilla (that’s the brown liquid in photo.) and beat again for a couple of seconds until incorporated.

Step Six:

Spread into a parchment lined pan and smooth-ish (it will still be slightly puffy and not completely smooth on top) with a spatula. Let sit at room temperature for at least 4 hours before proceeding. Don’t get antsy and try to go on without waiting at least 4 hours…I did the first time with bad results!

Step Seven:

After they have sat for at least 4 hours, using the parchment paper, transfer to a cutting board to shape into marshmallows.

Step Eight:

Cut off ½” of all four sides and save to make mini marshmallows.

Step Nine:

Cut remaining slab into 1” strips and then cut the ½” edges into mini marshmallows. Set the minis aside until you get to Step Ten.

Step Ten:

Cut strips into 1” squares (mine were more like rectangles)

Step Eleven:

(Optional but keeps them a little more separate)

Roll in Tapioca Starch (or toasted coconut or cocoa powder or cinnamon…many options!) Store at room temperature for at least a week (unless you use probiotics then the time is much shorter.)


Paleo Marshmallows and Hot Chocolate

This recipe is almost as easy as those not-so-great packets. To make this into a gift, mix together the dry ingredients (using coconut sugar as sweetener) for 4 or more servings and place in a jar. Add a bag of marshmallows and tie with a ribbon card that contains the Gift Instructions below.


  • Cocoa Mix Ingredients (per serving)
  • 2 tbsp cocoa powder

  • 2 tbsp maple syrup, honey or coconut sugar*

  • 1 scoop collagen or collagen creamer

  • Hot Cocoa Ingredients
  • 3/4 cup Raw Milk or your alternative milk of choice (I used almond)

  • ½ tsp vanilla extract

  • Homemade marshmallows (step-by-step instructions above)


  • Stir the cocoa powder, liquid sweetener of choice (If using coconut sugar, read on), collagen and vanilla together to make a paste.
  • Heat milk until just steaming then gradually stir into the cocoa mixture until combined.
  • Top with as many marshmallows as desired. (I limited it to two for the photo, but of course added more once I put the camera down!)
  • Directions if Using Coconut Sugar:
  • Stir together cocoa powder, coconut sugar, collagen and vanilla. Add a couple of tablespoons of heated milk to create a paste. Add remaining milk and stir until combined. Top with marshmallows.
  • Gift Instructions:
  • Multiply the ingredients times 4 or as many servings as you would like to make and place in decorative jars. Tie a bag of homemade marshmallows to the jar or make a little gift basket with the jar and bag. Make instruction cards that say: “Mix 5 tbsp of mix together with ½ tsp vanilla extract. Heat 3/4 cup milk of choice until just steaming. Stir a couple of tablespoons of heated milk to create a paste then gradually add remaining milk and stir until combined. Top with as many marshmallows as you like. Enjoy and Merry Chistmas!”

Note: There may be affiliate links in this post. That means I may make a small commission that helps keep this blog running, but you never pay more. In fact, you often get a discount.  Any products I recommend are products I love to use myself. If you have any questions, please see Disclaimer for more info or to contact me regarding this policy.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.